January 26th, 2014 9:14pm
While I agree that Hopkins lacks some professionalism in some instances over the last couple of seasons, that's no reason to hate on the organization itself, most of my animosity there is directed towards him rather than the membership and the Cadets as a whole, they don't deserve that. I rather loved Side by Side, I thought it was a very interesting and unique way of trying to blend and create something new from multiple forefronts musically and visually. Even if you don't like the shows themselves, their hornline and percussion have been on fire recently, no denying that. It's just a matter of when they decide to pick and execute a design that wins. This years seems about as ambitious as the last few odd number years, and is at risk of gaining some resentment due to the presence of the narration throughout as it is planned, we'll see if it pays off.
Current thoughts on what I expect in 2014 as far as the top 5 goes: (copying what I said on DCP)
Blue Devils after a non championship year come out firing on absolutely all cylinders, so it'll be hard to beat them See 2009 and 2012. They have a formula, staff consistency, and talent that will not fail them any time soon.
Crown is coming off of a championship season, so I'm not sure what is going to happen. Either it's going to be they found their niche and they will go on a run for a few years or they will be good, but it just doesn't click. Hope the drums keep improving, thought they were stronger in 2013 as compared to 2012. Front ensemble was fantastic.
Bluecoats, I want so badly for them to find what has and hasn't worked the last few years, and do everything that worked at 1 time. I feel like the issue has boiled down to 2 things, in my unprofessional opinion that probably doesn't mean a thing. Visual and General Effect. Guard isn't bad, visual isn't bad, shows aren't bad, but when you have top 4 brass and percussion, that doesn't really cut it. They need to be GREAT. Fix the technique, get the guard a little better, and that's all good. Another issue I have, is the front halves of their shows the last few year, Creep in 2011, Filet and Flume in 2012, the intro and City life in 2013 are all absolutely fantastic, but by the closer it really feels like they are winging it in the show concept. And I remember at the last two theatre casts in June Cesario saying that exact thing. They are usually better by finals, but not completely fixed. You can't have the show start off with a huge bang and go out with a fizzle, if anything it should be the other way around, but it should be the whole show. The Hymn of Axicom piece they have announced, I guarantee, will be one of the best moments of the year, if not THE moment, but so was Creep. And that show finished 7th. I think the meaning behind that piece is a huge hint to the show theme, which could be EPIC, so please don't let this opportunity slip by. Have that amazing pinnacle moment in the show, but don't let that be all we remember from it.
Then there's SCV. Who has gone 7th, 6th, 5th, 4th the last four years. The dream team of a staff and the talent they've gotta be attracting lends me to think they'll medal, easily. Just keep doing what you've been doing, and you're set.
Cadets, will be talented. No doubt. Show theme could work, or backfire. They do patriotic very well, but I hope the narration works. Not at all sure where this will go.
So my top 5:
1st - Carolina Crown
2nd - Blue Devils
3rd - Bluecoats, I'm going off of my gut here. Purely. ONLY 3rd if this show is as good as I think it's going to be. If it's another good moment without consistency throughout the production show, Phantom and Cavaliers could do some damage.
4th - Santa Clara Vanguard, more realistically top 3, but like I said, taking a chance with Bluecoats.
5th - Cadets, because I have no idea.